Toby heads to Whispering Key to hide from a scandal and keep his identity as advice columnist Aunt Hagatha secret. His plan unravels when he meets Beale Goodman — a huge, gentle, utterly wholesome man who rescues feral cats and ends up rescuing Toby too. Beale agrees to pose as his fake soulmate, but the act quickly feels real, especially with the island community embracing them as a couple. As Tony starts to realise he’s finally found something worth staying for, his old secrets threaten to catch up with him.
This one just didn’t work for me. The story felt far too chaotic, and the humour — which should have been a highlight — quickly tipped into irritating rather than charming. I kept hoping it would settle into the same enjoyable rhythm as the first book in the series, but it never quite found that balance. Instead of feeling fun and warm, the constant noise and over‑the‑top antics drowned out the romance and left me more frustrated than entertained. This was an MM story with mature content.
Buy from Amazon





